Preventive strategies for sleep problems within the primary care setting start by understanding the causes of and contributors to sleep problems in general (see Box 3), as well as those experienced by Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander patients particularly, and then by risk factor management (see Box 4).
The prevention of sleep disorders starts with recognising that sleep is foundational to health and wellbeing, that it is related to all physical and mental health and that it should be taken seriously because of these facts. Normalising discussions about sleep health and the importance of good sleep is important for all GPs within healthcare settings by initiating and including these discussions in initial and ongoing assessment, as well as in conversations with families and individuals. Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people may not always view or understand sleep in the same way as non-Indigenous Australians, so these initial discussions with a GP are especially important. This means culturally appropriate screening tools for sleep problems in Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples are needed. This is a significant gap in sleep healthcare, although there are some emerging materials being developed (eg TESS; see Useful resources.28 If possible, screening tools should be delivered with the assistance of Aboriginal health practitioners/health workers to aid in translation and the culturally appropriate delivery of questionnaires. Furthermore, means to improve OSA risk and sleep health habits should take into consideration cultural safety and the appropriateness of recommendations, and be inclusive of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people knowledge (eg using online resources to promote relaxation prior to bedtime that have been developed by Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people; see Useful resources). Several sleep resources have been developed for Australian healthcare professionals, including GPs, but none of these include culturally appropriate resources (see Useful resources). The lack of culturally specific sleep resources, diagnostic tools and management pathways are a major barrier for primary care in assessing and managing sleep health, and there is great need for further research in this area. The identification of enablers and barriers to sleep health care, informed by community members, as well as programs codesigned from the outset for health service delivery, is likely to improve sleep health in Aboriginal and Torres Strait islander populations.
Assessment in children
Obstructive sleep apnoea
Parents/carers may not mention snoring and sleep problems in children unless specifically asked. If indicated, simple questions asking about noisy breathing during sleep and screening for enlarged tonsils or adenoids is recommended.8,19 Other features that may alert to the presence of OSA include unrefreshing sleep despite a seemingly adequate quantity of sleep (wakes tired and grumpy), waking with a dry mouth, secondary enuresis and poor weight gain.19 Symptoms of OSA should be considered in any child who presents even with mild snoring, with enlarged tonsils and/or disturbed or unrefreshing sleep.8,19 Screening questionnaires that identify symptoms of OSA in children are available, although they have not been culturally validated (see Box 1). Assessment of the presence or severity of OSA in children is confirmed with a sleep study (PSG), which involves non-invasively monitoring multiple physiological channels to record sleep and cardiorespiratory parameters. Sleep studies can be arranged through referral to a paediatric sleep centre or specialist sleep paediatrician, and parents can stay with the child overnight. Although PSG is the gold standard for sleep assessment, alternative sleep tests, including abbreviated studies with limited channels performed at home, show promise, with overnight oximetry having a strong predictive value for OSA.19
Insomnia
For children with reported or suspected behavioural insomnia of childhood, taking at least a 24-hour sleep history is a useful approach (refer to Useful resources).51,59 Screening questionnaires used to identify symptoms of insomnia in primary care can include the Sleep Disturbance Scale for Children,18 and the BEARS (Bedtime issues, Excessive daytime sleepiness, night Awakenings, Regularity and duration of sleep, Snoring)17 (see Box 1). These questionnaires can differentiate physiological sleep problems (such as snoring) from behavioural sleep problems indicative of insomnia. However, none of these questionnaires has been validated in Aboriginal or Torres Strait Islander populations. Newly available Let’s Yarn About Sleep sleep health assessments and sleep diaries for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander adolescents have been developed in consultation with Aboriginal or Torres Strait Islander communities (see Useful resources). For children who are presenting with insomnia symptoms, providing advice about healthy sleep behaviours is recommended (Box 2; see Useful resources).
Assessment in adults
Obstructive sleep apnoea
If a patient presents with excessive daytime sleepiness, snoring or overnight gasping for breath, an assessment for OSA should be undertaken. To assess daytime sleepiness, the ESS has recently been adapted for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander adults, the Top End Sleepiness Scale (TESS).28 The TESS uses a pictorial version, and although validated in communities in Northern Territory, may also be adapted to other communities, where appropriate,28 and may be most helpful with patients from remote locations. For suspected OSA, validated screening tools that align with Medicare OSA screening questionnaires include the OSA50, ESS and STOP-BANG with a detailed medical history (for detailed screening recommendations, see Useful resources for RACGP-endorsed primary care resources for OSA) with modifications available for adolescents. To confirm the presence of OSA, a diagnostic sleep study should be facilitated through the sleep specialist/physician/clinic.
Assessment of risk factors for OSA is also recommended. These are presented in Box 4 and included here.14 For example, alcohol use worsens the severity of OSA, with more respiratory events accompanied by greater falls in blood oxygen levels throughout the night, and increases sleepiness.60 In untreated OSA, it is recommended to avoid alcohol. Being overweight/obese increases the risk of OSA in adults, although less so in children. Weight loss decreases the severity of OSA, with studies showing that a 10% weight loss predicted an approximate 26% decrease in OSA severity.61
A non-supine sleeping position may be beneficial in patients with OSA, especially if the patient reports experiencing significant symptoms or this is determined using PSG information. Compared with the supine position, a non-supine sleeping position decreases the number of respiratory events.62
To confirm the presence of OSA, referral to a sleep specialist/physician/clinic for a diagnostic PSG sleep study should be facilitated. A PSG is conducted either in a sleep laboratory or increasingly via a home-based study. In-laboratory PSG is performed with a sleep scientist in attendance throughout the night. However, in-laboratory PSG can be costly, with long wait lists, and is not always accessible to or suitable for those living in regional and remote areas. Accordingly, portable home sleep study testing (set up by a sleep scientist or by a patient if possible), which shows reasonable diagnostic accuracy, is receiving more attention and may be beneficial for patients to reduce wait times and increase patient comfort, and may be more suitable for patients residing in rural/remote communities. There are four types of sleep studies:
- Type 1: Full PSG in a sleep laboratory, attended by a sleep scientist, comprising seven or more channels (gold standard)
- Type 2: Full PSG at home, unattended by a sleep scientist, comprising seven or more channels (most robust home sleep study)
- Type 3: Portable testing at home, attended or unattended by a sleep scientist, comprising three to six channels
- Type 4: Portable testing at home, unattended by sleep scientist, comprising one to two channels.
Detailed guidelines are available at the ASA website to inform decisions regarding the type of sleep studies best suited for patients.
For patients diagnosed as having symptomatic or significant OSA, avenues to facilitate CPAP therapy should be explored, including ongoing monitoring, compliance assessment and adherence to therapy.
Insomnia
For adults with suspected insomnia, questionnaires such as the Screening Condition Indicator or the Insomnia Severity Index (see Box 1) are recommended with modifications for adolescents (see RACGP-endorsed primary care resources for insomnia in Useful resources for a full list of screening recommendations). Seeking information about patients’ (un)healthy sleep behaviours is important but is not effective as a standalone avenue for treatment. Referral to practitioners of CBT-i would formalise whether the insomnia is a sleep initiation (getting to sleep) or a sleep maintenance (staying asleep) problem. GPs can assess any potential benefits of short-term medication for adults presenting with symptoms of acute insomnia (in concert with education about healthy sleep behaviours; see Box 2).15,16 However, the use of short-term medication must be closely monitored. Checking for comorbidity of OSA may also be appropriate.58
Box 4. Primary care recommendations for the ongoing prevention and management of the risk factors for obstructive sleep apnoea (OSA) and insomnia in adults8
|
For detailed recommendations, refer to Obstructive Sleep Apnoea - Management of Risk Factors
- Limit the use of alcohol (less than two standard drinks, consumed at least four hours before bedtime) and certain sedatives and anti-anxiety/antidepressant medications (eg benzodiazepines)
- A 5–15% weight reduction for overweight or (morbidly) obese patients by behavioural modification, diet, exercise and bariatric surgery
- Change in sleep position (ie sleeping in a non-supine position for patients with positional OSA)
- For patients with comorbid insomnia, cognitive behavioural therapy for insomnia should be used to improve insomnia symptoms
|
Recommendations for managing sleep issues in Aboriginal or Torres Strait Islander people are in three areas: awareness and knowledge; actions; and tools and resources.
Awareness and knowledge
GP/clinician understanding
Based on findings from the national Sleep health in Indigenous Australians report,4 sleep problems are highly prevalent in Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people and have the potential to affect overall health and wellbeing. The treatment of sleep disorders, such as OSA and insomnia, can significantly reduce blood pressure in people with hypertension,26,63,64 improve excessive daytime sleepiness, reduce anxiety and depression, reduce days of absenteeism and improve quality of life.56,58 There is also robust evidence that treating insomnia simultaneously improves compliance with CPAP for OSA patients,58 antidepressant response in patients with depression,56 mood and quality of life.34,38 So, it is imperative that GPs ensure they have adequate knowledge about sleep health and sleep disorders and that sleep health information is discussed as part of any clinical history taking, particularly with those who are at risk of poor mental health and at risk of or with chronic conditions such as diabetes, hypertension and cardiovascular disease.54 Ongoing professional development in sleep can be undertaken with many free and subscribed resources (see Useful resources).
Patient and community knowledge
Health literacy around sleep is not high in the general community.2 Discussions with patients and their families about sleep and its relationship to all other physical and mental health issues is an important part of healthcare delivery for all patients, and especially for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander patients. Opportunities to expand knowledge about the importance of good sleep health and how to achieve it within families and communities should be exploited.
Cultural differences and similarities
Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples have similar sleep problems to non-Indigenous Australians. However, the contributing factors and risk factors are greater in Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples when there is social disadvantage and a higher prevalence of chronic disease. A major priority for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander patients is effective communication and cultural respect when healthcare is discussed. Understanding that Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people may not view or discuss sleep in the same manner as non-Indigenous Australians is also important.
7,9 Importantly, due to the kinship and family structure in Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander culture, the role of a patient’s family and Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander staff in encouraging sleep health discussion is vital. In this context, there are broader social determinants that affect an Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander patient’s ability to practise sleep health recommendations.
7 However, it is worth sharing the information on the impact of sleep loss on physical and mental health to encourage family-/community-level conversations on sleep health and encourage the adoption of sleep health messages when possible, being aware that whole families may need to be involved in this information sharing.
Actions
Initial evaluation and subsequent screening
To date, including sleep health in clinical conversations and using brief screening tools have not generally been included in primary care unless the patient presents with symptoms indicative of OSA and/or insomnia. There have been no recommendations about screening for sleep disorders in a primary care setting, which obviously contributes to the underdiagnosis of sleep disorders.13 However, although not specific for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples, currently the National Centre for Sleep Health Services promotes knowledge and the engagement of primary care professionals in the management of OSA and insomnia. GPs should initiate discussions about sleep with all patients, as well as responding to complaints or symptoms of poor sleep, including asking about signs of poor sleep, sleepiness, daytime fatigue and family history of sleep disorders opportunistically, when clinically indicated and/or as part of an annual health check. There is significant potential for simplified, community-based models of care (eg using screening tools and limited channel sleep study testing) within primary care. Training Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander health workers and/or nurses to diagnose and treating sleep disorders within Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander communities, including in rural/remote regions, is a priority. Generic sleep evaluation tools are available (see Box 1) for both adults and children as an initial evaluation of the nature of the sleep problem. For example, investigating reported sleepiness with the TESS, ESS or the Paediatric Sleepiness Scale (Box 1) may inform the GP enough to investigate further by screening for a specific sleep disorder (eg OSA). In children and adults presenting with symptoms of snoring or noisy mouth breathing, assessment for OSA is imperative. For patients presenting with difficulties getting to sleep or staying asleep in the absence of snoring, assessment for insomnia with self-report (for adults and adolescents) or via parental/carer report (for children) is warranted .
Ongoing assessment of individuals and families
The state of sleep health should be monitored over time as a regular inclusion in patient healthcare, especially for those with comorbidities and chronic health conditions. Patients presenting with symptoms of sleep disorders, such as OSA, should be informed of the long-term complications of untreated OSA, the relative merits of the various diagnostic and treatment options available and the management of risk factors (eg obesity). If medications are advised for chronic insomnia, ongoing monitoring is necessary, especially if the patient has undertaken CBT-i with a sleep psychologist.
Referral
New guidelines endorsed by the RACGP that provide GPs with appropriate clinical management, treatment and referral options for OSA and insomnia have been released (see Sleep health primary care resources in Useful resources).14 Referral pathways include adult sleep specialist/services, paediatric sleep services and ear, nose and throat services. For acute or chronic insomnia in adults, and behavioural insomnia of childhood, if indicated, referral to a sleep trained psychologist is warranted and referral pathways can be found through the Australasian Sleep Association and the Australian Psychological Society (see Useful resources).
Tools, referrals and resources, including patient information and education
Familiarity with screening tools, including culturally appropriate tools where available
GPs should be aware of the range of generic and specific tools and screening questionnaires available and whether they are culturally validated. It is important to use culturally appropriate materials where possible, especially because inappropriate questionnaires can lead to misdiagnosis or missed diagnosis. However, there are specific Medicare criteria for direct access to sleep studies, which require the use of specific questionnaires. A wide range of other materials, and resources on various websites, are also available (seeUseful resources; Box 1). GPs should also be aware of referral pathways for OSA and insomnia in both adults and children.
Availability of hardcopy appropriate patient education materials and resources
It is important to provide information and education on contributing factors to poor sleep (Box 3) and advice for healthy sleep behaviours (Box 2) as hardcopies and/or online for both children and adults with presentations of sleepiness and symptoms of insomnia, including difficulties in initiating or maintaining sleep. When possible, the clinical approach and tools for the diagnosis and management of sleep issues should be guided by resources that are developed with Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander community members and are responsive to the cultural needs of the patients. Although such resources are scarce, emerging research and programs (eg Let’s Yarn About Sleep; see Useful resources are offering meaning and culturally responsive tools to facilitate sleep health discussion in the primary care setting.