Background
Maintaining hearing health at all stages of life is important for health and wellbeing. Healthy hearing promotes communication and social connections with family and friends, increases the ability to participate in team and community activities and supports learning. Hearing loss can cause significant disability, and impaired communication can adversely affect relationships with family and friends and within workplaces. Hearing loss is associated with delayed child development, impaired speech and language development and lower educational opportunity.1,9,31 Untreated hearing loss in adults can have health, psychosocial and economic effects, including reduced quality of life, social isolation, depression and underemployment.9,32,33 Hearing loss is associated with an increased risk of poor outcomes in the elderly, including hospitalisation and dementia.2,9
Hearing impairment in Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people is an important and common health issue. Although the full extent of hearing impairment is not known, the rates of hearing loss are much higher than in the non-Indigenous Australian population. Self-reported rates of hearing problems/ear disease were 14% across all ages in the National Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander health survey (2018–19).33 The health survey offered a voluntary hearing test for participants aged seven years and over, and, from 290,000 tests, 43% of people were found to have measured hearing loss, with 79% not reporting long-term hearing loss. Measured hearing loss was higher in remote areas (59%) than in non-remote areas (39%).3,33
Hearing loss has a high prevalence in incarcerated populations, particularly in Aboriginal and Torres Strait islander people.34–36 It is a risk factor for the involvement of young people in the criminal justice system, including through links to communication problems, behaviours and mental health problems.37,38 The disproportionate incarceration rate reflects a failure of prevention and early detection to protect against the negative sequelae of hearing loss. For individuals who enter the prison system with hearing loss, their condition can exacerbate the existing challenges of adjusting to the prison environment. Communication difficulties are likely to make it harder to understand instructions from staff, participate in educational or rehabilitative programs and maintain social connections, and may negatively affect mental health. It is crucial to ensure that individuals with hearing loss have equal access to communication, education, healthcare and support services to mitigate the potential negative outcomes associated with their condition. Providing appropriate services (including sound amplification and hearing aids) not only can improve the wellbeing of incarcerated individuals with hearing loss, but can also contribute to reducing recidivism rates and enhancing the overall effectiveness of the correctional system.
Optimising ear health and preventing hearing loss are important goals, as is adequately treating hearing loss to prevent its negative consequences. It is critical that clinicians and patients recognise that most hearing loss is preventable. The high rates of hearing loss in Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people are predominantly due to persistent OM and its consequences. OM is a common condition that generally starts in infancy or early childhood and disproportionately affects Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander children. Much can be done to prevent hearing loss and promote healthy hearing throughout the lifespan by focusing on the primary prevention, early detection and prompt and effective management of OM.
There are other preventable causes of hearing loss that are important in primary care. Epidemiological studies have found strong associations between hearing loss in adults and cigarette smoking, obesity, diabetes and other risk factors for cardiovascular disease.39,40 The causation is unclear, but it appears that vascular changes may contribute, further suggesting some age-related hearing loss may be preventable and the progression of hearing loss decreased.9 Hearing loss in mid-life is recognised as a risk factor for dementia, and older people with hearing loss have higher rates of hospitalisation, death, falls, frailty and depression even when known risks for these conditions are considered.2,9,41
This topic focuses on the prevention of hearing loss, including OM. In this edition of the National Guide we have also provided new guidance on other preventable causes of hearing loss in adults, including noise-induced hearing loss.
Hearing loss and hearing impairment
There are different types of hearing loss, the two main types being conductive and sensorineural hearing loss. Conductive hearing loss is caused by impairment of the outer or middle ear, which prevents the transmission of sound to the inner ear. The most common causes are impacted wax, OM and otosclerosis (where the bones in the middle ear can become fixed in place). Sensorineural loss relates to dysfunction in the cochlea or nervous auditory apparatus. If hearing loss has both conductive and sensorineural components, it is referred to as mixed. Hearing loss can range in severity and be temporary or permanent.9
Hearing loss is based on an average of the hearing threshold at several frequencies and is graded as mild, moderate, severe and profound according to the degree of deviation from normal hearing thresholds as tested by audiometry (Table 1). Hearing impairment is categorised by the degree of disability associated with hearing loss in each ear or in the better ear.4
Self-reported hearing loss can be unreliable, so diagnosis must be made after audiological testing.42 However, hearing tests have limitations and can underestimate the problems caused by hearing loss. For example, OM can cause hearing loss that varies over time, so average hearing levels based on a single assessment may provide an underestimate.4 Furthermore, OM has a substantial effect on hearing for frequencies outside those routinely tested. Finally, a hearing test does not account for the effect of age of onset, duration of hearing loss, language spoken, processing ability and environmental factors.
Disabling hearing loss is defined as greater than 40 dB in the better-hearing ear in adults and greater than 30 dB in the better-hearing ear in children.4 However, even at lesser degrees of loss, both adults and children can experience problems in daily life. Unilateral hearing loss can still cause problems, including in language development.43 Furthermore, hearing loss can cause disability even if it is present for relatively short periods of time, such as when a child has recurrent OM during crucial periods of development and learning (first and early years of life).
Table 1. Grades of hearing loss in children4 |
Grade |
Corresponding audiometric ISO value (in the better ear) |
Performance |
None or slight |
20 dB or lower |
No or very slight hearing problems
Able to hear whispers |
Mild |
21–31 dB |
Not able to hear and repeat words spoken in normal voice at a distance greater than 1 m |
ModerateA |
31–60 dB |
Not able to hear and repeat words spoken in a raised voice at a distance greater than 1 m |
Severe |
61–80 dB |
Not able to hear most words when shouted into the better ear |
Profound |
81 dB or greater |
Unable to hear or understand even a shouted voice |
ADisabling hearing loss refers to hearing loss greater than 40 dB in the better-hearing ear in adults and greater than 30 dB in the better-hearing ear in children. |
Causes of hearing loss across the lifespan
There are multiple causes of hearing loss, both preventable and unpreventable (Figure 1). Notable causes of preventable hearing loss are discussed in more detail below.
Figure 1. Causes of hearing loss over the lifespan
Note, causes shown in italics are considered preventable.
Reproduced from AIHW with permission.44
Otitis media
The most common cause of preventable hearing loss in Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people is OM, which usually starts in infancy and childhood.3 OM is inflammation and infection of the middle ear space. The most common types are acute OM (AOM), in which there is fluid in the middle ear plus symptoms and/or signs of acute infection, and OM with effusion (OME), where there is fluid in the middle ear but no acute infection present4 (Box 4). All forms of OM cause conductive hearing loss that may fluctuate according to the health of the middle ear.
Box 4. Types of otitis media4
|
- Otitis media (OM)
Refers to all forms of inflammation and infection of the middle ear. Active inflammation or infection is nearly always associated with a middle ear effusion (fluid in the middle ear space).
- OM with effusion (OME)
Presence of fluid behind the tympanic membrane (‘ear drum’) without any acute symptoms. Other terms have also been used to describe OME, including ‘glue ear’, ‘serous OM’ and ‘secretory OM’. OME may be episodic or persistent. A type B tympanogram or reduced mobility of the tympanic membrane on pneumatic otoscopy are the most reliable indicators of OME.
- Episodic OME
OM as defined above of duration less than three months.
- Persistent (chronic) OM with effusion
Presence of fluid in the middle ear for more than three months without any acute symptoms or signs of inflammation.
- Acute otitis media (AOM)
General term for both acute OM without perforation (hole in the tympanic membrane) and acute OM with perforation. AOM is defined as the presence of fluid behind the tympanic membrane plus at least one of the following: bulging tympanic membrane; red tympanic membrane; recent discharge of pus; fever; ear pain; or irritability. A bulging tympanic membrane, recent discharge of pus and ear pain are the most reliable indicators of AOM.
- Recurrent AOM
The occurrence of three or more episodes of AOM in a six-month period, or occurrence of four or more episodes in the past 12 months.
- Chronic suppurative OM (CSOM)
Persistent ear discharge through a perforation (hole) in the tympanic membrane lasting two weeks or more and tympanic membrane perforation large enough to allow penetration of topical antibiotics into the middle ear space (generally >2% of the pars tensa). The size of the perforation should be determined and recorded because this directs management, and the duration of discharge is often difficult to establish.
- Tympanostomy tube otorrhoea
Middle ear discharge (otorrhoea) through tympanostomy tubes (or ‘grommets’). This may occur early after insertion of tympanostomy tubes or may be delayed and may be chronic or recurrent.
- Dry perforation
Presence of a perforation (hole) in the tympanic membrane without any signs of discharge or fluid behind the tympanic membrane. Some people also refer to this as inactive CSOM.
- Attic perforation
This is a perforation in the superior part of the tympanic membrane. A perforation in this location may be associated with a deep retraction pocket or cholesteatoma.
- Cholesteatoma
Abnormal growth of skin cells in the middle ear, which continues to grow, eventually causing breakdown of surrounding structures (middle ear ossicles, facial nerve, base of skull), resulting in hearing loss, facial paralysis or intracranial complications.
|
OM is more common in Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander children than in non-Indigenous Australian children.43–46 Chronic OM, including CSOM and tympanic membrane perforation, is highly prevalent in rural and remote Aboriginal communities, where only 10% of young children were found to have bilaterally normal ears in prevalence studies as recently as 2018.45
OM is a spectrum of disease ranging from mild to severe. In its mildest forms (AOM and OME), OM is a common childhood condition in all populations, from which most children improve spontaneously.4 Children who have frequent episodes of AOM or have persistent OME are of most concern due to more frequent or longer periods of hearing loss and their higher risk of developing severe disease or complications. CSOM is a severe form of OM in which there is persistent discharge through a hole in the ear drum, which is extremely difficult to treat, can persist into adulthood and can cause long-term hearing loss.47
Although conductive hearing loss due to OM is often regarded as a temporary condition, it will be a chronic problem in chronically diseased ears.4 Episodic OME and AOM cause a mild hearing loss during the periods when there is fluid in the middle ear space, whereas chronic OM (persistent OME and CSOM) can cause moderate hearing loss. Sensorineural hearing loss may occur secondary to long-term chronic OM.
Transient hearing loss due to OM is important to manage and monitor actively as per clinical guidelines to make sure it resolves.4 If a child has recurrent AOM or persistent OME and is awaiting diagnostic audiology or tympanostomy tube surgery, provide education and support for parents/carers and families to adopt active strategies to help the child with language development and learning, and to decrease the disability caused by hearing loss (Box 3).
Effective prevention, diagnosis and management of OM in infancy and childhood will reduce the prevalence of hearing loss and support childhood development and learning. OM is linked to upper respiratory tract infections, so minimising the transmission of infections in childhood is likely to decrease the risk of OM. The earlier OM occurs, the greater the likelihood of recurrent OM and complications.24 Thus, preventing respiratory tract infections in infancy is important, including through immunisation and household-level behavioural strategies (eg toddler hand and face hygiene) that minimise the transmission of infections to infants.24 Hearing loss during the critical period of sensorineural development in infancy and early childhood can affect auditory processing and communication skills that may be lifelong and difficult to correct.43,48,49 Relevant preventive strategies are discussed in the next section. Readers are also directed to the 2020 Otitis media guidelines for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander children4,50 for detailed information on the prevention and management of childhood OM.
Antenatal and childhood infections
Congenital infection with rubella or CMV can cause deafness and developmental delay.10,21 In Australia, infection rates with rubella remain extremely low due to widespread immunisation programs, with Australia judged to have officially eliminated rubella in 2017.51 Rubella elimination is defined as the absence of endemic rubella cases for a period of ≥12 months in the presence of adequate surveillance.52 However, the risk of congenital rubella remains, including due to migration or vaccine hesitancy. Congenital CMV infection is rare but does occur, and there is no immunisation available.53 CMV infection in pregnancy is often asymptomatic, and there is a lack of awareness of the risks of CMV during pregnancy.22 The best prevention of CMV is avoidance of maternal infection during pregnancy, including through handwashing14,22 (Box 2). Antiviral medications are used for infants with congenital CMV to improve outcomes, including hearing outcomes.53,54
Immunisation against other infective causes of acquired hearing loss in childhood, such as meningococcal disease, pneumococcal disease, measles, mumps and varicella, are important preventive strategies.10,13
Noise-induced hearing loss
Voluntary recreational noise exposure at unsafe levels, also known as unsafe listening practices, can decrease hearing health at all ages and the resultant rising hearing loss is considered a global threat.13 It is a particular risk in young people, including through the use of personal listening devices and attendance at loud entertainment venues.7 Recurrent or even single exposures can lead to transient or permanent hearing loss and tinnitus, and may increase the risk of age-related sensorineural hearing loss.13 Some people may be more susceptible to noise-induced hearing loss than others, including due to genetic predisposition, chronic conditions such as diabetes and exposure to cigarette smoke.9,13&
Education and the promotion of safe listening practices are critical and require more emphasis. International and national initiatives seek to promote healthy hearing and safe listening practices by providing accessible information on how to limit noise exposure to permissible levels (noise volume and exposure duration), the use of ear plugs and headphones and monitoring listening levels, such as through phone apps. This includes the World Health Organization Make Listening Safe initiative55 and Australian Government initiatives through the National Acoustic Laboratories, such as Know Your Noise and HEARsmart56 (see Useful resources).
Occupational noise exposure is another important cause of hearing loss, the risk of which is similarly exacerbated by tobacco smoking and chronic conditions such as hypertension and diabetes.57 A 2017 Cochrane review showed evidence that stricter workplace legislation, and the proper use of hearing protection devices in noisy environments, can prevent occupational noise-related hearing loss.8
Few studies have explored the prevalence of noise-related hearing disorders affecting Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples. Furthermore, few health professionals and families are aware that excessive exposure to loud noise over prolonged periods can damage hearing. In terms of interventions, Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander health workers have an important role to play because they can best inform families about the dangers of too much loud noise, and of the particular dangers for children with a history of ear disease. A recent Cochrane review reported that reduced noise exposure can be achieved with the use of personal earmuffs and earplugs, with adequate instruction.8 Stricter legislation may reduce noise levels, but the effects of hearing loss prevention programs are not yet clear.8
Hearing health and ageing
Hearing loss becomes increasingly common with age. Age-related hearing loss (presbycusis) is usually bilateral and symmetric and most pronounced at higher frequencies.9 Of the adults aged over 55 years who underwent the voluntary hearing test in the 2018–19 National Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander health survey, 82% had hearing loss in one or both ears.3
Degenerative effects of ageing on the auditory system are the leading cause of adult-onset hearing loss, but there are also potentially modifiable contributors to the incidence and severity of hearing loss: the accumulated effects of exposure to noise; therapeutic drugs with ototoxic side effects; and chronic conditions that can accelerate hearing loss.9 Therapeutic drugs that cause hearing loss are aminoglycoside antibiotics (including administration of neomycin through a perforated tympanic membrane), non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs, antineoplastic agents, quinine and loop diuretics.26,58 As noted previously, prevention and the management of risk factors and conditions that are associated with hearing loss, including cigarette smoking, obesity, diabetes and cardiovascular risk factors, may promote healthy hearing throughout the lifespan.9
Preventing hearing loss and the management and amelioration of hearing loss are vital in older age given the evidence of a link between hearing loss and dementia, decreased wellbeing, depression and social exclusion.2,9